Elian gonzalez affair Interesting Essay Topic Ideas

The Elian Gonzalez Affair

0 0
2596 words
9 pages

An Analysis of the Liberalism in the United States and the Case of Elian Gonzalez in Terms of Political Analysis

0 0
1732 words
3 pages

The Elian Gonzales affair was a highly publicized international dispute over a five-year-old Cuban boy named Elian Gonzales, who was the subject of a controversial custody battle between his father in Cuba and his uncle in Miami in 1999 and 2000 The young boy had been found off the coast of Florida, in the United States, on November 25th, 1999. An international custody struggle ensued as the United States government, his Miami relatives, and the Cuban government all fought for custody. Ultimately, the United States Supreme Court ruled in favor of returning Elian to his father in Cuba, and he was returned after a highly publicized raid by the United States Justice Department in April of 2000. The Elian Gonzales affair brought about much debate and discussion over Cuban-American relations, the Cuban Adjustment Act of 1966, the scope of the U.S. government’s powers, and parental rights. These topics have been the focus of many argumentative essays over the years, and here are some of the best examples. The first example is an essay by William M. LeoGrande on the implications of the Elian Gonzales affair on Cuban-American relations. This essay examines the history between Cuba and the United States and how the Elian Gonzales affair harmed the improved relations between the two countries that had been achieved in the years prior. The essay further argues that U.S. foreign policy regarding Cuba and Cuban-Americans has been shortsighted and does not take into account the potential benefits from improved relations. The second example is a piece by S. L. Gardner on the Elian Gonzales affair as an example of governmental overreach. This essay argues that the U.S. government’s decision to forcibly remove Elian from his uncle’s home in Miami was a violation of parental rights, as well as a disregard for the rule of law. The author further argues that the U.S. government exceeded its authority and acted in a manner that was not in the best interests of justice or the individual. The third example is an essay by Ismael Ramos on the Cuban Adjustment Act of 1966 and how it was related to the Elian Gonzales affair. This piece examines the application of the Cuban Adjustment Act to Elian’s case and whether the Act, which was designed to allow Cuban immigrants to stay in the United States, actually applied to Elian. The essay argues that the Act did not actually apply to Elian’s case and that the U.S. government wrongly applied the Act to Elian’s situation. The fourth example is an essay by Robert Parry on the Elian Gonzales affair and the U.S. government’s role in it. This essay argues that the U.S. government overstepped its authority in the affair and acted in a manner that was politically motivated, rather than guided by the law and justice. The author further claims that the U.S. government’s actions prevented a peaceful resolution of the case and that the use of force was a violation of the principles of international law. The fifth example is an essay by Tamar Jacoby on the importance of parental rights in the Elian Gonzales affair. This essay argues that the importance of parental rights was overlooked in the case and that Elian’s father, not his uncle, should have had custody of Elian. The essay further examines the implications of this ruling for other cases and argues that parental rights should be respected and upheld in all cases, even in the face of international pressure.